For centuries violent wars had raged in Europe. Harvests were destroyed, houses were plundered, families torn apart. Society was unsettled time and again. The raw images of the battlefield that through the invention of photography now also reached the home front, did serious damage to the idea that war was essential for defending the glory of king and country. And so, in the course of the 19th century, the peace ideal blossomed as never before. The political tensions and resulting threat of war on the threshold of the 20th century only added to the popularity of the spreading peace movement. Throughout Europe and America peace organizations were founded, inspired by the ideas of famous writers and pacifists such as Leo Tolstoy, Bertha von Suttner and Alfred Nobel.
Abbenhuis, M., Ch.E. Barber and A.R. Higgins (eds.), War, Peace and International Order?: The Legacies of The Hague Conferences of 1899 and 1907, London and New York, Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, 2017.
The initiative of Czar Nicholas II to organize an international peace conference came at exactly the right moment. During the First Hague Peace Conference of 1899, 26 countries came together to speak about disarmament and about the possibility of international jurisdiction, which led to the establishment of the Permanent Court of Arbitration. In 1907 a second peace conference was organized in The Hague, in which 44 countries participated.
This volume brings together some of the latest scholarship on the legacies of the Hague peace conferences in a comprehensive volume, drawing together an international team of contributors. The exact legacies of the two Hague peace conferences remain unclear. For contemporaries, the Hague conferences were controversial events. The fear that the results of these conferences, the 1899 and 1907 Hague conventions, might limit States' sovereignty, compelled them to ignore or limit their application. Diplomatic and military historians, who cast their gaze to 1914, traditionally dismiss the events of 1899 and 1907 as insignificant footnotes on the path to the First World War. On the other, many internationalists, peace activists en international lawyers welcomed the conferences with enthousiasm. Experts in international law posit that The Hague’s foremost legacy lies in the manner in which the conferences progressed the law of war and the concept and application of international justice: they set a notable precedent for the future of international organisation as well as for the rise of international judicials forums.
This book attempts to assess the history and on-going relevance of the Hague conferences, the conventions they brought into being, the institutions they established and the precedents they set. The fact that the Hague system became a permanent development after 1907 is easilly forgotten. A third peace conference was planned for 1915. Unfortunately, the events of the First World War overtook the proposed event and an official Hague peace conference was never held, despite several attempts. After 1918, a new age of collective security based on the League of Nations' mandate seemed to overshadow the Hague conferences' promise for the judicial and international organisation of the world. Yet, The Hague's influence continued to radiate. The Permanent Court of Arbitration remained in session. The Permanent Court of International Justice, established in 1920, evolved into the International Court of Justice in the aftermath of the Second World War. Both courts still reside in The Hague, accomodated within the Peace Palace. The city of The Hague also continues to revel its connections to the 1899 and 1907 conferences, as more than 160 international organisations are housed within its boundaries. The chapters of this book all highlight how essential The Hague has been - and continues to be - to the development of international law and in the pursuit of peace.
As noted in the introduction (page 5), the chapters of the book do not offer a comprehensive history of the conferences nor do they narrate all historical and contemporary applications. To access those, readers must look elsewhere. Our suggestion would be: the PPL online catalogue! What the chapters do attempt is to highlight how relevant the Hague conferences are to shaping the history of the modern world.[number of readers: 901]
A selection of relevant publications from the Peace Palace Library collection
- Abbenhuis, M., Ch.E. Barber and A.R. Higgins (eds.), War, Peace and International Order?: The Legacies of The Hague Conferences of 1899 and 1907, London and New York, Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, 2017.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
- Introduction: Unbridled Promise? The Hague’s Peace Conferences and Their Legacies, Maartje Abbenhuis
- Justifying International Action: International Law, The Hague and Diplomacy Before 1914, William Mulligan
- Peace Through Law: The Hague Peace Conferences and the Rise of the Ius Contra Bellum, Randall Lesaffer
- Muddied Waters: The Influence of the First Hague Conference on the Evolution of the Geneva Conventions of 1864 and 1906, Neville Wylie
- Reconsidering Disarmament at the Hague Peace Conference of 1899, and After, Andrew Webster
- More than Just a Taboo: The Legacy of the Chemical Warfare Prohibitions of the 1899 and 1907 Hague Conferences, M. Girard Dorsey
- Sub Silentio: The Sexual Assault of Women in International Law, Sarah Gendron
- The Duel of Honour and the Origins of the Rules for Arms, Warfare and Arbitration in the Hague Conferences, Robert A. Nye
- Writing for Peace: Reconsidering the British Public Peace Petitioning Movement’s Historical Legacies After 1898, Annalise R. Higgins
- The Hague as a Framework for British and American Newspapers’ Public Presentations of the First World War, Thomas Munro
- Norway’s Legalistic Approach to Peace in the Aftermath of the First World War, Marta Stachurska-Kounta
- Against the Hague Conventions: Promoting New Rules for Neutrality in the Cold War, Wolfgang Mueller
- The Neutrals and Spanish Neutrality: A Legal Approach to International Peace in Constitutional Texts, Yolanda Gamarra
Relevant PPL-keywords for further research
- Hague Conventions (1899 and 1907)
- History of international law
- International Court of Justice
- International dispute settlement
- International humanitarian law
- Judicial settlement of international disputes
- Laws of war
- Peace conferences
- Peace Palace
- Permanent Court of Arbitration
- Permanent Court of International Justice
- Public international law
- The Hague Peace Conference (1899)
- The Hague Peace Conference (1907)